Are there differences in the performance of students attending different types of schools? A new study found that compared with teenagers who go to public schools, homeschooled teenagers are less likely to get a college degree, but they report fewer dangerous health behaviors and fewer “character advantages.”
Previous research by researchers in a new study looked at the association between primary and secondary education types and student academic performance Publish Point out in PLOS ONE. However, research on the topic of “beyond academic performance” is “rare,” because these data can help parents, educators, and policy makers make informed decisions.
The researcher wrote: “The school experience of primary and secondary schools may be crucial to shaping the trajectory of personal development and well-being in the future, and shaping the well-being of students can be said to be one of the important goals of education.” “Therefore, when comparing various types of primary and secondary schools It’s very important to understand students’ long-term achievements and happiness in different aspects of life.”
In their study, the researchers studied how the type of schooling during adolescence affects “the health and well-being of subsequent adulthood.” They used data from the Growth Today Study (GUTS), which involved 12,288 students aged 11 to 19, with an average age of 14.56. The baseline data collected in 1999 included information such as the type of school the participants attended.Among them, 80.56% are enrolled in public schools, 9.67% are enrolled in private religious schools, 8.12% are enrolled in private independent schools, and only 1.66% are enrolled in Homeschooling.
The result data is mainly collected from the 2010 wave of the GUTS questionnaire. If not, it is collected from the 2013 or 2007 wave.
Researchers found that there was “almost no statistically significant difference” between children attending public schools, private religious schools, and private independent schools. Public Science Library famous In the press release. However, there are some “significant” differences between students who go to public schools and those who go to school at home.
Specifically, those who are educated at home are more likely to forgive others and are 51% more likely to participate in religious ceremonies. They also have more frequency of voluntary service, have a greater sense of mission in life, and are also less likely to use marijuana. In addition, they have fewer sexual partners in their lifetime. However, they are 23% less likely to obtain a college degree in their youth and are “likely” at greater risk of developing post-traumatic stress disorder.
The researchers wrote: “Although the association in our study needs to be further investigated in future studies, the results here provide some suggestive evidence that it may be worthwhile to support the mental health of homeschooling students.”
However, the researchers pointed out that the results may not be applicable to the general population, because most of the participants were children of non-Hispanic whites and nurses.
As for why homeschooling students are unlikely to get a college degree, the researchers speculate that this may partly reflect lower academic performance or low interest in college. They pointed out that this may also “reflect the status quo of some American universities,” which restrict the admission policy of homeschooling students.
The researchers wrote: “In addition to the desire for academic learning and educational achievement, school choice is certainly influenced by many factors, such as beliefs, values, and logistical considerations.” “Therefore, considering many aspects of children’s long-term The results can be said to be relevant to decision-making. Therefore, the results of this study may help inform decision makers, educators, parents, and other education stakeholders that they can make decisions by considering evidence about broader educational goals and outcomes Decide.”
Photo: Pixabay
