We can’t rely on banks to tackle climate crisis, comments from a senior banker suggest
Stuart Kirk, Global Head of Responsible Investment at HSBC Asset Management, Ask Investors Last Month: “Who cares if Miami is 6 meters underwater in 100 years? His widely reported comments point to the serious risks of relying on the financial sector to voluntarily report and act on the climate crisis.
Evidence is mounting that there are serious systemic problems with the prevailing market-led approach to green finance. In late May, German police raided the office Asset manager DWS and its owner Deutsche Bank have been involved in greenwashing after a whistleblower said DWS claimed its investments were more sustainable than before. Meanwhile, Larry Fink, CEO of giant asset manager BlackRock, push back Oppose the idea that private investors should ensure that the companies they invest in take action against the climate crisis.Explore further be opposed to Taking into account indirect emissions that occur in the company’s value chainsuch as those generated by corporate investments, which tend to be biggest part company emissions.
These developments are in line with growing trends questioning validity Claims that the private financial sector is incorporating environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors into its investment decisions. Beyond the recent controversies, hard data on capital flows to fossil fuels tells a much clearer story.recent Tackling Climate Chaos 2022 The 60 largest global banks have provided $4.6 billion in fossil fuel financing in the six years since the Paris Agreement was signed, with the 100 companies contributing most to expanding the fossil fuel industry in 2021 alone, report documents show. $185.5 billion.
UK-based HSBC is a good example. While Group CEO Noel Quinn, claim he “Totally disagree” Kirk said about Miami, but the bank’s activity suggests otherwise. HSBC remains 13th largest funder Global fossil fuels, Europe’s largest funder Expansion of the oil and gas sectorand only last year Lobbying for the Net Zero Banking Coalition Postponing and downplaying its climate rules.
HSBC remains the world’s 13th largest investor in fossil fuels.
Continued mega-fossil fuel financing shows that investors currently do not believe that governments meeting their climate commitments, known as stranded assets, threaten the value of their fossil fuel investments.Conversely, in April, investment strategist Lynn Alden’s Stock picks of the week are new oil and gas pipelines that reflect what is believed to be high fossil energy prices, weak regulators on climate action and the recent troubling inflate The government will make these lucrative investments. While this remains the case, it is a dangerous illusion to expect the financial sector to voluntarily and quickly move away from dirty investments when more information is available on climate-related risks.
Unfortunately, the current main approach to green finance, in Working Group on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD), relying on this assumption. TCFD was created in 2017, HSBC and Deutsche Bank A growing number of financial firms have issued TCFD-related disclosures on climate-related financial risks, while continuing to fund fossil fuels or conduct dubious greenwashing of their products. in England, government practice, centered on the implementation of the Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR), following the same paradigm.And the Bank of England, although it is early leadership So far reluctant to go beyond data collection and stress testing when putting climate on the central bank’s agenda, seeing its primary role as Understand the risks associated with transition and seeking Protect the financial sector Climate change – not protecting the climate from financial impacts.
to avoid a planetary catastrophe, we need to rapidly reduce emissions and rapidly divert financial flows from dirty fossil fuels to renewable energy, home renovations, energy efficiency and related investments that support the transition.market-led approaches such as disclosure or Doubtful net zero goalssuch as those in Glasgow Net Zero Finance Alliance (GFANZ) umbrella, will not provide this – certainly not at the required speed or scale.
Evidence of banks’ actual lending behaviour suggests HSBC’s Kirk is far from the only one who sees climate as “The work these people make me do”, – another tick-tick exercise. We need mandatory adjustments in the financial sector rather than relying on market self-adjustments with the Paris AgreementTon. The Bank of England and the government must coordinate the implementation of proactive Credit Guidance PolicyActively intervene in the market transfer money flow Stay away from harmful activities by taking the following measures higher capital requirements Oppose dirty loans and provide loans to desirable activities through incentives.
ECB President Christine Lagarde Say The central bank needs “have an open mind” about bolder policy such as targeted green funding schemes – because “‘If we don’t try, then we have no chance of success“.
Photo: iStock
